Managed vs Unmanaged Network Switches _ How to Select the Right One?

Network switches are essential components in any network setup. They play a crucial role in control and communication. Two types of network switches are managed and unmanaged. Both of these network switches have their own unique features that distinguish them from each other. The selection of the right network switch depends on the needs of your organization. This blog offers a comparison of managed vs unmanaged network switches to help you determine which one best suits your needs.

Managed Network Switches:

These network switches offer an advanced level of control and fine-tuning. They come with advanced features, such as SNMP, and more, for network configuration and monitoring. They support various features, including link aggregation and the Spanning Tree Protocol. Remote management and software-defined networking enable easy management of large networks. 

Pros of Managed Network Switches:

There are several advantages of managed network switches for users.

Network Control: 

Managed switch comes with the latest features, such as VLAN, port forwarding, and Quality of Service for better control. It allows users to prioritize various types of traffic to make sure smooth performance across your network. 

Security Features: 

Managed network switches are preferred due to their security features. These support encryption for better protection and monitoring.  You can shut down the network in case of any potential threat for a better management plan. 

Scalability: 

Managed network switches provide users with greater flexibility and scalability. When your network grows, you can configure additional devices to accommodate your needs. They also allow users to create multiple VLANs to segment network traffic and handle sensitive data safely. 

Network Monitoring and Remote Management:

It offers real-time network performance for diagnosis and troubleshooting issues. It helps users to maintain an efficient and smooth-running network. Many switches enable network administrators to make changes to the network without requiring physical intervention. These features make it useful for large networks. 

Cons of Managed Switches: 

Some drawbacks of using managed switches are;

Higher Cost:

Managed network switches are expensive due to their best capabilities and advanced features. Therefore, they are not suitable for small businesses or individuals seeking effective budget solutions. 

Complex: 

Managed network switches are complex and require more expertise to set up and configure. To install them properly, you will need the help of IT experts. If you lack expertise or have a business without any dedicated IT staff, it is not suitable for you. 

Better Control: 

With managed network switches, you can monitor and control which data can move on the network and which can’t. Furthermore, they are also preferred due to high-quality services and better functionality. 

Unmanaged Network Switches?

Unmanaged network switches are plug-and-play devices that don’t require any configuration. These switches come with basic features that use QoS services to monitor the performance of the network. Due to a fixed configuration, these are suitable for homes and small businesses. They are perfect for businesses that don’t have an IT staff, as they don’t require any special settings, such as a carrier unmanaged Gigabit PoE switch. 

Pros of Unmanaged Network Switches:

Some benefits of unmanaged network switches for your business are;

Simple and Easy to Use:

Unmanaged switches are plug-and-play devices that are easy to set up and use. They automatically begin routing traffic without the need for any manual configuration. You can use it for a small network with only a few devices to connect, such as a star & daisy network. 

Cost-effective: 

Unmanaged network switches come with only fewer features and are also not tough to manage. Therefore, they are less expensive and highly affordable for businesses that lack a budget and don’t need advanced features.

Reliability:

Unmanaged switches, including unmanaged Gigabit PoE switches and others, are usually more reliable with limited features and setting options. As they have fewer chances of failure and configuration errors. 

Cons of Unmanaged Switches:

Unmanaged switches are not suitable for all types of businesses due to these drawbacks. 

Lack of Advanced Features:

Like managed switches, unmanaged network switches don’t have any advanced management tools. So, they don’t offer that level of control and monitoring to its users. That means you can’t prioritize traffic or manage network performance or troubleshooting. 

No Security Control: 

Unmanaged switches typically have minimal security measures. They don’t come with built-in security features, such as access control lists (ACLs) or any port security. Therefore, there is a high risk of attacks associated with unmanaged switches. 

Limited Scalability: 

As your network grows, with an unmanaged switch, you can’t add new devices to your network. As they don’t offer scalability options to their users to manage more devices, traffic, and complex network configurations. 

Managed vs Unmanaged Network Switches: Comparison:

How to Select the Right Network Switch for Your Business:

When selecting a suitable network switch for your network, consider the following factors. 

Size of the Network: 

When choosing a network switch, first evaluate your business needs. For example, if you have a small network with only a few devices, you can use an unmanaged network switch. But if you have a larger network that prioritizes traffic or segregation, a managed network switch is suitable for you. 

Network Complexity: 

A managed network switch allows users to meet their complex needs. If your business handles sensitive data, you can opt for a managed network. Its advanced security measures will allow for better control and monitoring. But if you have a small business network with no specific requirements, you can select an unmanaged 

Budget:

Budget and pricing of the network switches are also important points to consider. If cost is a primary concern, unmanaged switches offer an affordable solution for basic connectivity needs. For those who require advanced features, budget is not an issue for them. Managed switches will provide long-term scalability and control for them. 

Future Growth: 

If you plan for future growth, it is better to select a managed network switch. But if your business is small and has static networks, an unmanaged network switch is enough for you. 

Conclusion: 

Network switches are essential for connecting to various devices and maintaining communication. Managed and unmanaged network switches are some more popular switches for networking. Managed network switches are complex and feature-rich, offering advanced capabilities. They support various networking topologies and are suitable for large business. On the other hand, unmanaged network switches are simple and easy to install and use. They have basic features and also lack advanced security features. They are perfect for small businesses. Before selecting a solution, first analyse your business networking needs and budget. It will help you make a fine decision.